Jeffrey Keller

Jeffrey Keller is a New York City-based stand-up comedian and actor who seamlessly fuses his musical theater background with sharp, story-driven comedy. A graduate of Illinois Wesleyan University with a BFA in Musical Theatre, Jeffrey spent years on national tours—including a memorable stint as the "sexy UPS man" in Legally Blonde—before pivoting to the comedy stage. Known for his "hammy" theatrical edge and impeccable timing, he offers a fresh, relatable perspective as a straight man navigating a life filled with eclectic theater friends and everyday absurdities. Quickly rising to prominence, Jeffrey was named one of the New York Comedy Festival’s "Comics to Watch" in 2025. He gained massive viral fame as the internet’s favorite "gummy guy," a persona that helped propel him to sell out clubs across the country.